casting a glance & RR

casting a glance & RR

Edition Filmmuseum 76

In casting a glance one artist pays tribute to another as James Benning offers his filmic paean to Robert Smithson's legendary "earthwork" sculpture, the Spiral Jetty. With RR, his homage to the American railroad, the filmmaker brings an era to its close by going back to cinema's roots. Shot back-to-back over a period of two years, these works marked James Benning's farewell to analogue filmmaking and together constitute the profound "last words" on the film medium by one of its most singular innovators. This 2-disc set presents both films together with rare audio interviews in which Benning recounts the experience of making his "last" films and gives unique insight into his creative methods.

The films

casting a glance - USA 2007 - A film by James Benning - Premiere: September 15, 2007 (documenta 12, Kassel)

RR - USA 2007 - A film by James Benning - Premiere: November 2, 2007 (Österreichisches Filmmuseum, Wien)

About the films

Much of James Benning's recent work is characterized by the depiction of landscapes through the passage of time. In RR and casting a glance, produced simultaneously between 2005 and 2007, this approach is even more pointed: both films focus on landscape-altering figures. In the first instance it is the subject of trains, which trace the broad sweep of the American countryside; in the second it is Robert Smithson's famous "Earthwork", Spiral Jetty, which assumes a central role in Benning's intricate study of time. In both cases, the "protagonists" the train and the Jetty act as a kind of measuring device, laying bare not only a temporal becoming, but a myriad of historical and cultural connections as well.

The abbreviation "RR" stands for "Railroad" and can be seen on signposts at railroad crossings. In Benning's case, however, "RR" signals the much larger pioneering techno logical achievement that first made urban development possible in the 19th century. Seen today as something of an anachronism, the railroad, particularly in the form of the freight train, still stands as the cornerstone of the transcontinental economic infrastructure. There is hardly a more striking example of the dichotomy between freedom and exploitation, of frontier legend and irreversible devastation. Few artifacts of the modern age reflect bothtechnology's blessing and its curse more blatantly.

For two years, Benning assembled footage of trains throughout the U.S., depicting their movement through the frame of a static camera in a variety of surroundings. From start to finish, we see the steel monsters in their entirety, passing from idyllic and pristine landscapes to more populated and disfigured spaces, and finally through to the ends of the continent. The diversity of these locations corresponds in turn to a catalog of different forms of trains, speeds and shot lengths: ranging from very short to extremely long, the freight trains make their way by turns slowly or at great speeds, at times in the foreground orvanishing into the backdrop, through the changing scenery. Each episode brings with it an element of surprise and the unexpected: trains suddenly emerge from the vanishing point of the shot, or abruptly enter the image from the side, and each time it is the real dimension of the train that is the measure of the scene. Some shots (i.e. trains) involve only a couple of cars, while the longest train takes a good eleven minutes until it leaves the picture.

Many of the shots featured in RR were recorded during the sixteen trips that Benning made to the Spiral Jetty, at the northeast of the Great Salt Lake in Utah. In April 1970, the artist Robert Smithson had created a spiral-shaped, 1500 ft. long, 15 ft. wide tongue of land, describing it as "an immobile cyclone," a "slumbering earthquake in the midst of a surging stillness." Within a few years, however, the water level rose, submerging the stone spiral. It was only 30 years later, in 2004, that the work resurfaced, and since then, depending on the snowmelt of the surrounding mountains, it appears and disappears in turns.

This spontaneous play of nature is due not least to the fact that the originally black basalt rocks became gradually coated with a white layer of salt, only to be once again "washed black" by the rain. This process of entropy, which Smithson was aware of and indeed consciously initiated, is taken up by Benning as he "projects" his shots of the Jetty, assembled over the course of two years, onto a chronicle of its history since 1970. In a total of sixteen sequences, beginning with an "april 30, 1970" insert and ending with "may 15, 2007," casting a glance encapsulates the work's status of visibility by depicting the historical water levels (mathematically reconstructed) through corresponding shots. It is only with this additional information that the caliber of the film's construction comes to light, illustrating how time can expand itself, turning the present into the past as it does, yet without doing violence to the latter in the process.

Christian Höller

DVD features (Doppel-DVD)


  • casting a glance 2007, 77'
  • James Benning: Casting a Glance at casting a glance 2012, 17'


  • RR 2007, 107'
  • James Benning: RR - JB - QA 2012, 19'
  • 20 page bilingual booklet

Edited by: Österreichisches Filmmuseum
DVD authoring: Ralph Schermbach
DVD supervision: Oliver Hanley

First edition May 2012, Second edition November 2014

TV Format Original format Audio format Language Subtitles Region code

4:3 (PAL)
Dolby Digital 2.0
All Regions


Usually ships within 48 hours
Price: 29,95 EUR (incl. 19% VAT, excl. shipping)